Rankings
Most divisive: the current leaderboard
The biggest spread between a car’s best and worst criterion - where opinions about the car disagree most.
13 of 119
Cars rated
13
Ratings behind these boards
3.59/5
Site-wide mean
Used as the Bayesian prior for every car.
1 votes
Best-evidenced car
Alpine A110
-
1
Ford Mustang
GT 5.0 V8 · 2024 · Sports & Coupe
4 star spread
1 vote · Early days
Perf. 5
Utility 1
Rel. 3
7 /10
-
2
BMW M3
Competition xDrive · 2023 · Sports & Coupe
2 star spread
1 vote · Early days
Perf. 5
Utility 3
Rel. 3
7.2 /10
-
3
BYD Seal U
DM-i Boost · 2025 · SUV & Crossover
2 star spread
1 vote · Early days
Perf. 2
Utility 4
Rel. 3
7 /10
-
4
Dacia Sandero
Expression TCe 90 · 2025 · Hatchback
2 star spread
1 vote · Early days
Perf. 3
Utility 4
Rel. 5
7.3 /10
-
5
Ford Puma
Titanium 1.0 EcoBoost Hybrid 125 · 2021 · SUV & Crossover
2 star spread
1 vote · Early days
Perf. 4
Utility 5
Rel. 3
7.3 /10
-
6
Alpine A110
S · 2022 · Sports & Coupe
1 star spread
1 vote · Early days
Perf. 5
Utility 4
Rel. 4
7.4 /10
-
7
Audi A6 Avant
45 TFSI quattro · 2021 · Estate & Wagon
1 star spread
1 vote · Early days
Perf. 4
Utility 4
Rel. 3
7.2 /10
-
8
Audi Q5
40 TDI quattro S tronic · 2021 · SUV & Crossover
1 star spread
1 vote · Early days
Perf. 3
Utility 4
Rel. 3
7.1 /10
-
9
BMW 3 Series
330i · 2021 · Sedan
1 star spread
1 vote · Early days
Perf. 4
Utility 3
Rel. 4
7.2 /10
-
10
BMW iX3
50 xDrive · 2026 · Electric
1 star spread
1 vote · Early days
Perf. 3
Utility 4
Rel. 3
7.1 /10
Showing the top 10 of 13 rated cars. The rest are in the full catalogue.
Top of this board: Ford Mustang on 4 star spread from 1 rating.
How to read these numbers
- Overall is the weighted mean of the three criteria, shrunk towards the site-wide mean with five imaginary votes. A car with two ratings sits close to the middle; it has to earn its way out.
- Vote counts are shown everywhere a score appears. Confidence labels (Early days, Emerging, Established, Well rated) follow the same thresholds, so a 9.5/10 from one person is never presented as a fact.
- Divisiveness compares a car's own criteria: a comfortable, reliable, slow car scores a wide spread but a low overall. It is the closest thing here to a "love it or hate it" measure, and it is not a quality judgement either way.
- Cars with no ratings do not appear at all. A blank rank is not zero.